How Timing Works

There’s no PCI, no directional influence, just swing timing. Hitters rely entirely on MLB The Show 25 Stubs ratings and timing windows.

Why Timing Works Well

Easy to learn: Perfect for newcomers.

Old-school baseball feel: Focus is purely on timing, like classic baseball games.

Relaxed experience: Good for casual players or those just grinding offline.

Drawbacks of Timing

No precision: You can’t influence where the ball goes.

Limited online viability: You’ll struggle against human pitchers.

Stat dependent: Your hitter’s ratings matter more than your skill.

Verdict: Timing is best for casual players who want zero complexity. It’s not recommended for competitive or online play.

Offline vs. Online: Choosing the Right Hitting Interface

The right hitting interface often depends on whether you’re playing offline modes or online competition.

Offline Modes (Franchise, Road to the Show, March to October)

Directional or Timing can work well since AI pitchers are predictable.

Zone is still viable if you want to improve your skills for online play.

Online Modes (Ranked Seasons, Diamond Dynasty, Co-op)

Zone is king. Directional and Timing put you at a massive disadvantage.

Reaction time, PCI placement, and cheap MLB The Show 25 Stubs pitch recognition are key.